There are some extreme feelings being expressed in this thread. It's difficult to know when to yank the reigns a bit. To some extent I let the group talk it out when they can, as Ian is doing above with Tony.
I applaud Akil's restraint here. He presents ONE Muslim point of view below. (Remember, there are many brands of the Muslim faith, as there are many brands of Christianity). ESPECIALLY because he's biting his tongue and trying to figure out how to speak his mind without inflaming, I'm pasting a PM he just sent to me. As is...
Bill,
Hope u dont mind me pm'ing when I have something troubling me big time (as opposed to inflammatory posting on your forum).......
On July 4th, some threads that I posted were eliminated (withdrawn-as is your right) and I publicly stated that I suported that decision (and I still do)......
I know this is too much to respond to immediately, so take your time.....me in no big hurry.......I would rather pm you this rant than place it on your forum directly....that way, i only make you mad (not my intention-really)....seriously, that way, you are fee to do with it as you feel fit, no need to say anything that embarrasses you or me, publicly......
It is however, very disapointing that, the same editorial license has not been used in the matter of the "London-We are With You"- train bombing thread (have been waiting patiently).
The thread that you started to (I am assuming here) to show sypmpathyy with those who suffered in London seems to have degenerated into a lets nuke Muslim nations or let's nuke Muslim people's thread........
Perhaps there should be a separate thread for how to respond to the terrorists. rather than turning the thread of memorium for those who have died or suffered into a thread on "how to get revenge for London" or how to revenge against the Muslims" (clearly, some Muslims are responsible for terrorists bombings, so arent they all?.......)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We could Nuke the Middle east to Glass and I suspect those left would still bomb .
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
so glad we are not advocating making the innocent suffer for the misdeeds of few
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Once the money stops flowing over there, they'll kill each other over stuff like wether Muhummad became a prophet at 40 or was he born a prophet.. you know, important stuff like that.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
this seems somewhat off topic regarding the tradegy in London that we all agree was both senseless and wrong
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ignorance is the petri dish for hate
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed.
And Americans are as ignorant of the Muslims as the Muslims are Ignorant of Americans.
Can you see why I work so hard to educate both Muslims and non-muslims about each other?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No more oil bussiness = massive lentil and camel consumption. When that is all gone, they'll stoop to eating carob pods then when thats all gone, they'll eat each other. Eventually, the desert will swallow them all up and we'll be rid of them once and for all.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am not saying that there is no room for sentiments like this. As far as I can tell, Tony is letting out his frustration, which seems reasonable, although there might be different threads that might more readily hold such loose lips postings, separate from the thread decrying the recent tradegy......
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I made a comment once before about turning the MId east into a sheet of glass.. but that's unrealistic at best plus it's not what I'd truly want. Us pushing a button or two would be just as evil and cowardly as ordering or blackmailing an impressionable young man into a sucicide bombing, as Al Queida has been known to do.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
there has been a lot of evil and cowardly stuff on both sides.....when does it end.........
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To some extent, the same can be said for countries whose main product is the oil underneath their houses. This isn't about sweat equity; it's about tapping into a resource that they did little to produce and process. The power that comes from it then corrupts more than power that might come from a country with a greater work ethic.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
our country seems to have a better work ethic and despite that, we support the saudi oil cronnies and their wahabi sect that exports their fanatical brand of Islam the world over, pushing out more tolerant forms of Islam (especially those that are supportive of reasonable treatment of both genders).
We wouldnt know this, however, unless we got past our ignorance and our hatred of one another
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
That's a great long term goal but for now capturing, squeezing intel out of them, along with hunting and killing them where they squat is best.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
perhaps we could just torture any suspects we come across. Ooooops, torturing makes us as bad as them, and it seems that not only are we good at it, but we enjoy it, too. And it rarely brings viable intel....innocents havent anything to tell and innocents are the vast majority of those rounded up. How will you ever know who is tellking the truth and who is just telling you anything just to get you to stop torturing them........
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I just dont think these folks will give up because of military action .
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
that's right, military action wont solve this problem. If military action could have solved this problem, it would have by now. How many more countriues need to be invaded and would it help in the least? We already have forces in countries that we dont even know about fighting alqaeda (philipines, etc) and is it helping?
we are fighting on their soil, not ours, right?
well, it appears that that tactic is not working cuz now it is seeping back on to our soil......is it possible that our enemy wants to take the fight to us as bad as we want to take the fight to them?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For example, had I been the president of the United States, I would have authorized the use of a Neutron Bomb to irradicate Al Sadr and his filthy goons from the Mosque in Najaf. Yes, I would have had the commander clear out the city and then detonate a neutron bomb about.. oh... 100-200 yards from the mosque. The radiation would have killed everyone in it but the building would be just fine.. oh, and there probably wouldn't be as intense of an insurgency as there is now because that is where all the schit actually started. I will go so far as to say the insurgency in Iraq as it is now is directly related to how we handled Al Sadr.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A lack of moderating leads folks to take more and more radical positions.......I can give as well as take, but I dont think that you want to go down there, thus I am exhibiting some considerable self control, by not posting equally wacked out stuff.....
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Islam it self promots peace, but the muslim world is living in the middle ages.
So whats my point?
REFORM WILL TAKE A VERY VERY VERY LONG TIME.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Need I remind that Christianity would never have become reformed if not for the help of Islam and, Islamic scholars, etc.......Europe was in the midst of "dark Ages", had burned most, if not all of its books from the greek and roman times.......Europe came out of the middle ages with the help of Muslims (and Muslim scholars) and their decided openness as a society.....
Say that the world is round and I will jail your arse
say that the planets and the stars revolve around anything other than us and your dead meat......
ooooops, sorry, that was how you were treated under Christian reform methods....anybody need a good inquisition?
And when did the inquisition start? Just as soon as the Muslims were kicked out of Spain?
When was the most dangerous time for Jews in Spain? After the Chrstian king and Queen eliminated Islamic rule in Spain.......That is when the inquisition started........
should we continue to pretend that Christianity is this peaceful religion when we know that the inquisition was another massive example of converting people to chrsitianity by use of the sword (embrace catholism and renounce judaism or Islam or be killed-nice choice).......but who do we say does this deed?
your right bill, it is ignorance on both sides, of the other, that makes this fight so easy to perpetuate.......so what are you willing to do about it?